Editorial Policy

Know Your Surgery is a patient-facing editorial publication. We publish plain-English summaries of authoritative US medical sources on surgeries and health conditions. This page describes how our content is created, who is accountable for it, and the standards we hold ourselves to.

Who We Are

Know Your Surgery is led by Adeel Naeem Naqi, founder and Editor-in-Chief. The publication is read by patients, families, and caregivers preparing for procedures, learning about a diagnosis, or making sense of medical advice they have received. Adeel oversees editorial standards, source vetting, and the publication’s commitment to patient-friendly accuracy. He does not hold medical credentials and is not a practicing clinician. Read more on our About page.

Our Editorial Process

Every article we publish goes through a structured, four-step workflow:

  1. Research brief. A topic begins with a research brief that draws only from authoritative US medical sources. The brief identifies what claims will be made, where each claim originates, and what plain-English explanation will accompany it.
  2. AI-assisted drafting. We use AI tooling to structure and draft articles. AI is used for clarity, consistency, and breadth of topical coverage. AI is not used to generate medical claims that are not anchored to a sourced fact in the research brief.
  3. Human editorial review. A human editor reviews every article for accuracy against the research brief, plain-English clarity, citation density, responsible framing of risks and outcomes, and adherence to our medical responsibility standards. Articles are returned for revision if they promise outcomes, sensationalize risks, rely on unsourced claims, or read in ways that confuse rather than inform a patient.
  4. Publication and ongoing review. Articles are published with a visible publish date. Articles are reviewed at least once every 12 months for accuracy, source freshness, and alignment with current US clinical guidance. Topics in fast-moving areas (drug approvals, surgical techniques, new clinical guidelines) are reviewed more frequently.

AI Authorship Disclosure

Know Your Surgery uses AI tooling as part of its editorial process. We disclose this openly because patients deserve to know how the information they read is produced. AI helps us cover more topics, structure articles more consistently, and produce drafts faster than a small editorial team could unaided. Every article is anchored to verifiable US medical sources and reviewed by a human before publication.

We do not allow AI to produce medical claims that are not traced to a named US authoritative source. We do not use AI to generate fabricated clinician opinions, simulated case studies, or invented statistics. Composite patient examples are clearly labeled as illustrative and never presented as real individuals.

The combination of AI-assisted drafting plus human editorial oversight is a deliberate choice. We believe transparent disclosure of it is more credible than concealment.

Source Hierarchy

Our content is built only from authoritative US medical sources. Sources are ranked in three tiers:

  • Tier 1 (always preferred): National Institutes of Health (NIH), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), National Cancer Institute, National Institute of Mental Health, U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.
  • Tier 2 (major US academic medical centers): Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, Johns Hopkins Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, UCLA Health, Mount Sinai, and equivalent peer institutions.
  • Tier 3 (US specialty associations): American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS), American Heart Association (AHA), American College of Cardiology (ACC), American Cancer Society (ACS), American Psychiatric Association (APA), American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO), American Urological Association (AUA), and equivalents.

When tiers conflict, Tier 1 sources govern. Statistics carry the source name and year. Where US clinical practice guidelines exist, we reference them in preference to international guidelines.

For our public bibliography of source families, see our Sources & References page.

Fact-Checking

Every clinical claim in an article is traced to a named source from one of the three tiers above before publication. Statistics older than five years are flagged for review or replacement. Outcomes are described as ranges and probabilities rather than promises. Risks are stated honestly rather than minimized or sensationalized.

If a published article contains an inaccuracy, we treat it as a serious failure and act on it under our correction policy below.

Correction Policy

If we publish an inaccuracy, our commitments are:

  • Acknowledgement within five business days of receiving a credible report
  • Investigation of the concern with our source materials
  • Update of the article promptly when a correction is warranted, with a visible “Updated:” notice on the page identifying what was changed
  • Public retraction when a substantive error has been published, with a clearly visible note explaining the retraction

To report a correction, email editorial@knowyoursurgery.com with the article URL and the specific concern.

Update Cadence

Every article is reviewed at least once every 12 months for accuracy, source freshness, and alignment with current US clinical guidance. The review date appears on the article. Articles touching on fast-moving topics — new drug approvals, evolving surgical techniques, updated clinical guidelines — are reviewed more frequently as needed.

Conflict of Interest

Know Your Surgery currently does not run sponsored content, paid editorial placements, or affiliate links. If this changes in the future, we will disclose any commercial relationship clearly on every article it touches and add a separate disclosures section to this page. We will never accept payment to alter clinical content, change recommended sources, or skew the framing of risks and outcomes.

What We Are Not

To be explicit about our scope:

  • We are not a clinical practice and do not see patients.
  • We do not employ practicing physicians.
  • We do not provide diagnoses, treatment recommendations, or personalized medical advice.
  • Our articles are not a substitute for professional medical advice from a qualified clinician.

We exist to translate authoritative US medical sources into plain English so patients can prepare better questions for their own clinicians. Nothing more, and nothing less.

Contact

  • Editorial inquiries and corrections: editorial@knowyoursurgery.com
  • General questions: Contact Us
  • Editor-in-Chief: Adeel Naeem Naqi (see About)

This page is reviewed and updated as our editorial practices evolve. Last reviewed: April 2026.